Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="orsal" data-source="post: 5427095" data-attributes="member: 16016">Except I don't see that as part of the character-judging process. I see that as a policy question, and LEW policy is discussed (by all interested players) and voted on (by all judges, not just character judges) in threads like this one. Character judging is a much more mechanical process -- checking over to see that all the numbers are what they should be. If the vote at the end of this thread is to approve Flaws, including all the ones listed in the d20srd.org SRD, then as character judges I wouldn't feel we had the authority to reject any character submitted with that flaw.So, if you think that some particular flaw is broken (meaning: the characters least penalized by it, would be penalized by rather less than a feat is worth), this thread is exactly the place to argue against it. We can always exclude it.Of course, if you want to make the argument that given almost any flaw it's possible to design a character who wouldn't mind it, that would be an argument against the flaw system rather than against specific flaws.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="orsal, post: 5427095, member: 16016"] Except I don't see that as part of the character-judging process. I see that as a policy question, and LEW policy is discussed (by all interested players) and voted on (by all judges, not just character judges) in threads like this one. Character judging is a much more mechanical process -- checking over to see that all the numbers are what they should be. If the vote at the end of this thread is to approve Flaws, including all the ones listed in the d20srd.org SRD, then as character judges I wouldn't feel we had the authority to reject any character submitted with that flaw. So, if you think that some particular flaw is broken (meaning: the characters least penalized by it, would be penalized by rather less than a feat is worth), this thread is exactly the place to argue against it. We can always exclude it. Of course, if you want to make the argument that given almost any flaw it's possible to design a character who wouldn't mind it, that would be an argument against the flaw system rather than against specific flaws. [/QUOTE]

Verification