Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="warpmind" data-source="post: 200256" data-attributes="member: 3998">Hey Binx: Your logic supposing Improved Critical a possible choice for the Mind-Blade has surprised me.&nbsp; ¿Should I then cast maximized fireballs with the Imps that my players are facing? I've read through the Imp description and I've read nothing that impedes him from using &quot;maximized fireballs at will&quot;... I (and I expect you too, for the sake of Pelor) suppose they CAN'T do that (unless you give him Sorcerer levels or whatever...). Their spell list only mentions some other spell but they're not examples BUT the only spells they can cast.&nbsp; Personally (and as an example), I suppose the soulknife is NOT necessarily profient with mind-blade use (conjuring a weapon doesn't make you automatically profient with it), but it usually is as most times have levels of fighter, rogue or the like. More: I think the true problem comes when the blade grows into a longsword which is martial and few classes have it in their &quot;Weapon Proficiency&quot; entry. But this is only an opinion, my personal opinion. You can like it or not but I don't say it's the way it has to be. &nbsp; All of us use home rules (as that exposed above and many others) but please don't assume that a PC can do something just because &quot;nowhere in the text says I can't&quot;.&nbsp; &nbsp; I find it good if anyone thinks Imp. Crit. can be used. It's logical. ¿Why shouldn't it? I would use it in my own campaigns, but don't take it as &quot;written&quot; or &quot;official&quot; or whatever because it's not.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="warpmind, post: 200256, member: 3998"] Hey Binx: Your logic supposing Improved Critical a possible choice for the Mind-Blade has surprised me. ¿Should I then cast maximized fireballs with the Imps that my players are facing? I've read through the Imp description and I've read nothing that impedes him from using "maximized fireballs at will"... I (and I expect you too, for the sake of Pelor) suppose they CAN'T do that (unless you give him Sorcerer levels or whatever...). Their spell list only mentions some other spell but they're not examples BUT the only spells they can cast. Personally (and as an example), I suppose the soulknife is NOT necessarily profient with mind-blade use (conjuring a weapon doesn't make you automatically profient with it), but it usually is as most times have levels of fighter, rogue or the like. More: I think the true problem comes when the blade grows into a longsword which is martial and few classes have it in their "Weapon Proficiency" entry. But this is only an opinion, my personal opinion. You can like it or not but I don't say it's the way it has to be. All of us use home rules (as that exposed above and many others) but please don't assume that a PC can do something just because "nowhere in the text says I can't". I find it good if anyone thinks Imp. Crit. can be used. It's logical. ¿Why shouldn't it? I would use it in my own campaigns, but don't take it as "written" or "official" or whatever because it's not. [/QUOTE]

Verification