Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Iosue" data-source="post: 6211125" data-attributes="member: 6680772">No the problem is we have a chocolate ice cream with a vanilla swirl, it's clearly labeled as chocolate ice cream, but now that we want to add chocolate chips to it the people who have been only eating the vanilla swirl are telling us that it's really vanilla ice cream, not chocolate, so we shouldn't add any more chocolate.Every edition has clearly labeled HP as not meat.&nbsp; Explicitly.&nbsp; Every edition.Despite that, some people have decided they play better as meat and have ignored the official definition.&nbsp; Fine.&nbsp; Their game, they can play how they like.Hit on a miss works entirely coherently with the meaning of HP in every edition.&nbsp; If it's problematic for people who treat HP as meat, then it is on them to houserule or ignore the rule, as they have done throughout history.There is no solving this chocolate vanilla mess.&nbsp; It's chocolate ice cream.&nbsp; It's always been chocolate ice cream.&nbsp; Some folks have been fine eating around the chocolate, but in the end it's still chocolate ice cream.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Iosue, post: 6211125, member: 6680772"] No the problem is we have a chocolate ice cream with a vanilla swirl, it's clearly labeled as chocolate ice cream, but now that we want to add chocolate chips to it the people who have been only eating the vanilla swirl are telling us that it's really vanilla ice cream, not chocolate, so we shouldn't add any more chocolate. Every edition has clearly labeled HP as not meat. Explicitly. Every edition. Despite that, some people have decided they play better as meat and have ignored the official definition. Fine. Their game, they can play how they like. Hit on a miss works entirely coherently with the meaning of HP in every edition. If it's problematic for people who treat HP as meat, then it is on them to houserule or ignore the rule, as they have done throughout history. There is no solving this chocolate vanilla mess. It's chocolate ice cream. It's always been chocolate ice cream. Some folks have been fine eating around the chocolate, but in the end it's still chocolate ice cream. [/QUOTE]

Verification