Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Magus_Jerel" data-source="post: 141283" data-attributes="member: 3940">The problem is - you can't make this choice without knowing who the drinker of the potion is going to be in this case.If the choice has to be made - what happens if the choice is illegal for the character involved?Your precedent is just fine - it COULD go either way - but it is easier to simply state that the potion works "as the spell" - and that the imbiber gets to make the choice upon recieving it.With the Resist Elements spell - you could make the argument that there are actually five versions of each of these spells, just as there are four versions of "Protection from Alignment".  With Alter Self - you can't make the same argument.It is really a flip of the coin tho - either way.  I don't see too many potions of alter self anyway IMC.</blockquote>