Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="robertsconley" data-source="post: 9675320" data-attributes="member: 13383">Your take that Blackmarsh is built around a level progression system doesn’t hold up. The core of your claim is that Castle Blackmarsh is a “starting area,” and that threats get worse the farther you move out, but it’s not how Blackmarsh is designed. I should know, I wrote it.Breaking it down.1. Castle Blackmarsh Is Not a Safe ZoneCastle Blackmarsh is a political and magical powder keg. The dungeons under it are full of unexplored, trap-ridden remnants from the reign of Atacyl Oathbinder. The elves don’t even have the manpower to finish clearing them. The humans resent Elven rules, and there are two conspiracies aimed at ending it. It's not a starter town, it’s a city with real dangers within and underneath it.2. There Is No Presumed Starting PointBlackmarsh doesn’t assume your campaign starts at Castle Blackmarsh. Viable entry points include:<ul> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">The halfling settlements in Newcombe (0409/0610)</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">The dwarven hold at Olden Hold (0217)</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">Ostrobard towns like Muncaester (1305)</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">Elven Stardell Falls (0804)</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">Vasan Viking strongholds like Castle Taldane (2505)</li> </ul>Each comes with distinct opportunities and threats. No one path is “the level 1 route.”3. Dangerous Creatures Are Mixed In EverywhereSome examples:0214: An old black dragon (HD 8) and her young (HD 7), just a few hexes from halfling farmland.0309: A ruined keep with ochre jellies and a black pudding (HD 10), right near the halfling  of Strangeholms0605: A planar breach where 12 flame demons (treated as 8 HD fire elementals) are fighting elves near Castle Blackoak1706: Four Rocs feasting on the remains of a Red Dragon, 10 miles from the fishing village of Ethanfeld.If this was a level-scaled setting, none of that would be anywhere near the starting areas.4. There’s No Consistent Difficulty GradientIf Blackmarsh followed a CR gradient, you’d expect dangerous locations on the fringes and safe ones near the center. But there are calm farming villages like Gamla (2509) or Daretop (2704) in the far corners, while mid-map areas like 0413 are full of kobolds worshiping a dangerous, untouchable magic sword.Danger isn’t placed to match player level, it’s there because of geography, history, and politics.5. Threat Placement Follows In-World LogicThe orcs are in the Crimson Hills (1911, 2207) because it’s a war-torn region near the Brotherhood of the Raven. The flame demons are where the elven forest is breached by a planar tear. That’s not CR-balancing, it’s worldbuilding.6. This Is a World, Not a TreadmillBlackmarsh doesn’t adjust to you. You adjust to it. You gather rumors. You scout. You ask the locals what they’ve seen. If you hear there’s a dragon in the hills and go anyway, that’s on you.The sandbox doesn't hide things until you're ready. It expects you to engage with the world intelligently.7. The Core Design Philosophy Is the Living World Sandboxthis is from the setting introConclusionBlackmarsh is not structured by level. It’s structured by history, geography, and factional influence. If you walk into the Crimson Hills at level 1 from the Duchy of the Ostrobards, you will probably die. That’s the point.It’s not about scaling the world to the players. It’s about players learning to navigate a world that doesn’t care what level they are.If you’re expecting 5e-style design, Blackmarsh is going to feel brutal. But if you want a sandbox that treats the setting as a real place, it rewards player agency and strategic thinking better than most published material.</blockquote>

Verification