Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Marshall" data-source="post: 5854622" data-attributes="member: 765">Great. Now go through the list of Rares and find one thats less than 25th level and that a PC would even notice he was carrying, let alone define his character with.Now go through the list of commons and find all the items that actually ARE character defining(Staff of Sleep and Charm, anyone).Now go through the list of Uncommons and find all math fix/accounting gimmicks that a ~5th level PC should be assumed to have(Bag of Holding,HHH,etc.)Rarity, as written and as recently updated, is incoherent at best. If you as a DM want to re-write the entirety of the lists of magic items to fit what you think it should be, go ahead. Just dont assume that the current lists will tell you ANYTHING about the value of any item.</blockquote>