Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="fett527" data-source="post: 2260854" data-attributes="member: 5458">My feelings are somewhat in between John Crichton and Wayne Ligon.&nbsp; I gave it an 8 of course.Most of it worked for me.&nbsp; I loved the battle scenes.&nbsp; I thought Grievous was very cool, I was looking for ward to his appearance after watching the Clone Wars cartoon.&nbsp; Teh emperor's machinations were great.&nbsp; Yoda vs. Emperor set against Obi-Wan vs. Vader was awesome!&nbsp; I really liked Hayden's acting much better this time.Where it didn't work for me:Chewbacca and Yoda.&nbsp; It was useless and he shouldn't have been added.&nbsp; Didn't like it all.The one scene I was looking forward to the most, the revealing of Vader in all his black robed glory, was disappointing.&nbsp; I didn't like the dialogue and, even if it fit, I didn't like seeing Vader stumble around.&nbsp; The force crush was cool, but over all this critical scene was a bust for me.&nbsp; Quite honestly this is what took it down to an 8 for me.&nbsp; I wanted something much different from this scene.But I will see it a handful more times to make sure of my opinions to be sure!</blockquote>

[QUOTE="fett527, post: 2260854, member: 5458"] My feelings are somewhat in between John Crichton and Wayne Ligon. I gave it an 8 of course. Most of it worked for me. I loved the battle scenes. I thought Grievous was very cool, I was looking for ward to his appearance after watching the Clone Wars cartoon. Teh emperor's machinations were great. Yoda vs. Emperor set against Obi-Wan vs. Vader was awesome! I really liked Hayden's acting much better this time. Where it didn't work for me: Chewbacca and Yoda. It was useless and he shouldn't have been added. Didn't like it all. The one scene I was looking forward to the most, the revealing of Vader in all his black robed glory, was disappointing. I didn't like the dialogue and, even if it fit, I didn't like seeing Vader stumble around. The force crush was cool, but over all this critical scene was a bust for me. Quite honestly this is what took it down to an 8 for me. I wanted something much different from this scene. But I will see it a handful more times to make sure of my opinions to be sure! [/QUOTE]

Verification