Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Lucas Blackstone" data-source="post: 6957037" data-attributes="member: 68942">I thought we agreed about common usage of words and ideas here. The common use of rolling a die is not behind obstructions so only you see the roll. Nothing indicates that the dice should be hidden. In Monopoly, one does not hide the dice when they roll. In Yahtzee one does not hide the dice when they roll. The rules of these games don't say the dice are not hidden, and everyone understands that. So why would it be different for this? I understand that many people like the idea, and that the game can be made to work with secret rolls, but if looked at objectively there isn't a reason to do it by the rules, and all the previously mentioned abilities suffer from it greatly. Also, for people who disagree , I notice that the parts of my posts bringing up the direct rules that show that the player can see the roll ( Combat Inspiration makes the direct note of it ) are always ignored. So while people say " There is nothing saying either way " I have shown that there is, while others have not. It doesn't say Combat Inspiration is the only reason the player sees the roll, it says that they see the roll and THEN can decide if Combat Inspiration will be used.</blockquote>