Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Ruin Explorer" data-source="post: 8985178" data-attributes="member: 18">Yes it is.Absolutely it is. Everything they've said about 5E&gt;1D&amp;D was true of both 3E&gt;3.5E and 1E&gt;2E and it was genuinely incredibly gaslight-y for them to claim otherwise. I know 90% of the people there were too young to remember 1E&gt;2E but the comments about 3E&gt;3.5E should be obviously nonsensical to anyone who played 3E from the start.No 3E adventure needed tweaking for 3.5E. Anyone who has it did is a liar. Barely any 1E adventures, if any, needed tweaking for 2E. I know this because we did it all the time without even thinking about it or questioning it. You just ran them. Depending on the DM you either used the stats for monsters printed in the adventure or the ones in MC/MM. And so on.EDIT - fine if we want to divide D&amp;D editions into two camps lol1) &quot;Not really an edition&quot; - 1E &amp; 2E, 3E &amp; 3.5E, and 5E &amp; 1D&amp;D2) &quot;Really an edition&quot; - 2E &amp; 3E, 3E &amp; 4E.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Ruin Explorer, post: 8985178, member: 18"] Yes it is. Absolutely it is. Everything they've said about 5E>1D&D was true of both 3E>3.5E and 1E>2E and it was genuinely incredibly gaslight-y for them to claim otherwise. I know 90% of the people there were too young to remember 1E>2E but the comments about 3E>3.5E should be obviously nonsensical to anyone who played 3E from the start. No 3E adventure needed tweaking for 3.5E. Anyone who has it did is a liar. Barely any 1E adventures, if any, needed tweaking for 2E. I know this because we did it all the time without even thinking about it or questioning it. You just ran them. Depending on the DM you either used the stats for monsters printed in the adventure or the ones in MC/MM. And so on. EDIT - fine if we want to divide D&D editions into two camps lol 1) "Not really an edition" - 1E & 2E, 3E & 3.5E, and 5E & 1D&D 2) "Really an edition" - 2E & 3E, 3E & 4E. [/QUOTE]

Verification