Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="gizmo33" data-source="post: 2452269" data-attributes="member: 30001">Quasquenton has started some very interesting threads about 1E, at least I count his series of "what were your experiences with module X" - so IMO I have nothing to say about his loyalty to one version or another.   355 words or not, I found his original critique to be somewhat lacking in a frame of reference that I understand.  I can go point by point and say "why is that a bad thing."For example: I3 has bandits, some of whom are 2HD and others have 4 hp.  So what?  Why is that a bad thing?   It seems Quasquenton has a reason but I can't figure out why it is.  What HD should bandits be?  Should they all be the same level?  Do they even know what their own level is?  Are they capable of detecting other bandit's level so they know who they should hang out with?  Is it a case of "master bandit" and "apprentice bandit"?  How does Quasquenton see these details as having a negative effect on the way he runs his adventures? I've been able to get Q- to say very little about his reasons behind his original 355 word critique.  IMO, yes there is a way you can explain your thoughts better, as I've tried to explain in previous posts.</blockquote>