Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Blue" data-source="post: 8099861" data-attributes="member: 20564">Yes, there are people who have read every spell.&nbsp; And we're talking PC options, not DM options like monsters.&nbsp; Though if you want to include that sort of category I read every magic item in the DMG looking for items to give out.No, I said that acendotal evidece that doesn't address what is being talked about doesn't count.&nbsp; That was really rather explicit in what I said, not sure how you missed it unless you're trying to set up a strawman.Let me restate the example I just gave:It's like if I said &quot;some people who live near the shore go to the beach several times a summer&quot;, and got a reply of &quot;I live in a land-locked state and don't go to the beach several times a summer&quot;. It doesn't matter if what you say is true or not, it doesn't interact with the point at hand.So, if by your own admission (since you claim I'm not counting your feedback) you aren't in the scenarios I suggested where people would be reading more, then it doesn't matter if you are another number on the side of &quot;player who only reads their class and level&quot;.&nbsp; We already know that category exists and it wasn't what was under discussion.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Blue, post: 8099861, member: 20564"] Yes, there are people who have read every spell. And we're talking PC options, not DM options like monsters. Though if you want to include that sort of category I read every magic item in the DMG looking for items to give out. No, I said that acendotal evidece that doesn't address what is being talked about doesn't count. That was really rather explicit in what I said, not sure how you missed it unless you're trying to set up a strawman. Let me restate the example I just gave: It's like if I said "some people who live near the shore go to the beach several times a summer", and got a reply of "I live in a land-locked state and don't go to the beach several times a summer". It doesn't matter if what you say is true or not, it doesn't interact with the point at hand. So, if by your own admission (since you claim I'm not counting your feedback) you aren't in the scenarios I suggested where people would be reading more, then it doesn't matter if you are another number on the side of "player who only reads their class and level". We already know that category exists and it wasn't what was under discussion. [/QUOTE]

Verification