Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="TheSword" data-source="post: 9466192" data-attributes="member: 6879661">How does that make for a better story other than some dogmatic standard of purity that most people don’t care about. It’s a story inspired by Tolkien’s works filling in a gap in events.She isn’t a warlike Amazon she’s a driven leader who can fight with a sword and a bow and ride a horse. She is being heroic on par with the other heroic characters in the series. You seem to want her to be passive. Just as people were angry that Arwen was active. Don’t understand why. But it goes back to this idea of dogmatic purity.Do you realise how silly it sounds saying something like Numenoreans aren’t superstitious. Or that the king of the elves couldn’t tell someone they’ve done enough damage and it’s time to go. You may not like the idea but they are entirely plausible and well within the writers purview.I’ve made previous comments about critics not being able to drive cars. See my comment to Sepulchrave.</blockquote>