Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Anubis" data-source="post: 490045" data-attributes="member: 2358">As I have pointed out MANY times . . . THE DMG ERRATA IS WRONG.  That errata was the most ridiculous thing ever published by WotC, honestly.Going by that errata, which CONTRADICTS EVERYTHING IN THE DMG, ANY item that requires Wish, Limited Wish, or Miracle SIMPLY CAN'T BE MADE AT ALL.  In fact, many other items that require spells with XP components can't be made until well into Epic levels if you use the errata.Look at the Ring of Three Wishes, which is supposed to cost 15,918 XP . . . If you go by the errata, however, the cost is increased to 505,918 XP, which is utterly ridiculous!ON THE OTHER HAND, something that none of you seem to have considered is a different interpretation of the errata.  In the book, it states that you don't need to pay ANY of the XP costs for the prerequisite spells.  Going by that logic, a Ring of Three Wishes perhaps would only require 918 XP.  PERHAPS what the errata was meant to do was require you to pay the XP cost for the prerequsite spell ONCE and ONLY once.  That would then require 15,918 XP for the Ring of Three Wishes, as the DMG states.In any event, if you used Limited Wish to create a Robe of the Archmagi, it would cost a total of 600 XP for the XP Components for Limited Wish.  That is what the rules state, and either the original rules OR the errata can be interpreted to state that quite clearly.I am willing to go to both Monte AND Skip, and I'd bet all the money I have that they'd agree with me on this.</blockquote>

Verification