Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="kreynolds" data-source="post: 491089" data-attributes="member: 2829">I never said that. The errata doesn't say that. Page 242 even states how a ring of wishes is created, stating that you only pay 15,000XP for the three wish spells that will be stored in the ring. The errata is merely reafirming what is stated on pages 241 and 242 (it is, however, at the same time, causing a bit of confusion).If you make a ring of wishes, you don't pay the XP cost for each day you cast the wish. You pay the XP cost for the number of wishes in the item, as it is the item that is duplicating wish three times, thus the cost of 15,000XP (5,000XP per wish), which brings the total price to 97,950gp, and this has not been errated, so it is correct to date.You only pay the XP cost for the number of times the item in question will duplicate the spell with an inherent XP cost, such as wish.Also, you'll notice that the DMG errata states that this error is only occurs once on page 244, and it can be found under Creating Weapons, but the mistake is not made under Creating Potions. Potions are one use items, and you only pay the XP cost once.See what I mean?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="kreynolds, post: 491089, member: 2829"] I never said that. The errata doesn't say that. Page 242 even states how a ring of wishes is created, stating that you only pay 15,000XP for the three wish spells that will be stored in the ring. The errata is merely reafirming what is stated on pages 241 and 242 (it is, however, at the same time, causing a bit of confusion). If you make a ring of wishes, you don't pay the XP cost for each day you cast the wish. You pay the XP cost for the number of wishes in the item, as it is the item that is duplicating wish three times, thus the cost of 15,000XP (5,000XP per wish), which brings the total price to 97,950gp, and this has not been errated, so it is correct to date. You only pay the XP cost for the number of times the item in question will duplicate the spell with an inherent XP cost, such as wish. Also, you'll notice that the DMG errata states that this error is only occurs once on page 244, and it can be found under [i]Creating Weapons[/i], but the mistake is not made under [i]Creating Potions[/i]. Potions are one use items, and you only pay the XP cost once. See what I mean? [/QUOTE]

Verification