Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="FoxWander" data-source="post: 5634046" data-attributes="member: 1356">Sorry Abraxus. After talking this over with my wife (who's also a DM) it looks like I have to switch sides and join the &quot;it doesn't work&quot; camp. She pointed out- the fact that rope can be pulled free AT ALL is what matters. That indicates the extra-dimensional space itself is not movable. The fact that it takes more force than the rope itself can take to pull it free (the rope would rip apart way before you could put 16K of force on it) simply reinforces this. The ED space is fixed at the point in the world where it is created by casting the spell. Trying to move it will destroy the rope before the ED space moves. In fact, I doubt you'd even bring the rope along with a teleport, since it's attached to an immovable &quot;object&quot;. My previous comparisons to Familiar Pockets or extra-dimensional magic items don't count because those effects are explicitly attached to movable objects. Those ED spaces are &quot;designed&quot; to go along with the item they're attached to. So I'd have to say the trick doesn't work after all.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="FoxWander, post: 5634046, member: 1356"] Sorry Abraxus. After talking this over with my wife (who's also a DM) it looks like I have to switch sides and join the "it doesn't work" camp. She pointed out- the fact that rope can be pulled free AT ALL is what matters. That indicates the extra-dimensional space itself is not movable. The fact that it takes more force than the rope itself can take to pull it free (the rope would [i]rip apart[/i] way before you could put 16K of force on it) simply reinforces this. The ED space is fixed at the point in the world where it is created by casting the spell. Trying to move it will destroy the rope before the ED space moves. In fact, I doubt you'd even bring the rope along with a teleport, since it's attached to an immovable "object". My previous comparisons to Familiar Pockets or extra-dimensional magic items don't count because those effects are explicitly attached to movable objects. Those ED spaces are "designed" to go along with the item they're attached to. So I'd have to say the trick doesn't work after all. [/QUOTE]

Verification