Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 8694158" data-attributes="member: 22779">Ah, but their choice DOES affect me.Because halflings and gnomes are in the PHB, that means that every single setting guide, adventure, and supplement MUST include both of them, regardless of whether or not they fit.&nbsp; You absolutely must include material for both races in every (or nearly every, I'm sure there are exceptions) book no matter what.I'm diminishing the interests of half a million people in the face of TWENTY TIMES more people.&nbsp; Ok, the math of that is off, but, you get the point.&nbsp; Again, I'm not advocating at all to remove them from the game.&nbsp; I'm simply shunting them to another book so they don't clutter up the game with a bunch of material that is so rarely used.&nbsp; They are in the same category as polearm tables.&nbsp; They just aren't needed in the PHB.&nbsp; And, you keep pointing to Level Up. Why?&nbsp; Do you honestly think that the revised game is going to be more complex than currently?&nbsp; Hey, The World's Largest Dungeon is about a thousand pages, so, I guess every future module should be a thousand pages too.&nbsp; <img src="http://www.enworld.org/forum/images/smilies/erm.png"&nbsp; class="smilie" loading="lazy" alt=":erm:" title="Erm&nbsp; &nbsp; :erm:" data-shortname=":erm:" />&nbsp; Why are you repeatedly pointing a book from another company?&nbsp; Do you really think they're going to double or triple the size of the PHB?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 8694158, member: 22779"] Ah, but their choice DOES affect me. Because halflings and gnomes are in the PHB, that means that every single setting guide, adventure, and supplement MUST include both of them, regardless of whether or not they fit. You absolutely must include material for both races in every (or nearly every, I'm sure there are exceptions) book no matter what. I'm diminishing the interests of half a million people in the face of TWENTY TIMES more people. Ok, the math of that is off, but, you get the point. Again, I'm not advocating at all to remove them from the game. I'm simply shunting them to another book so they don't clutter up the game with a bunch of material that is so rarely used. They are in the same category as polearm tables. They just aren't needed in the PHB. And, you keep pointing to Level Up. Why? Do you honestly think that the revised game is going to be more complex than currently? Hey, The World's Largest Dungeon is about a thousand pages, so, I guess every future module should be a thousand pages too. :erm: Why are you repeatedly pointing a book from another company? Do you really think they're going to double or triple the size of the PHB? [/QUOTE]

Verification