Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Phion" data-source="post: 7823769" data-attributes="member: 6917357">Is there academic studies on the use of x card? Is there unbiased quantative or qualitative surveys? From what I know the answer is no. Someone came up with the x card because it would hypothetically help to prevent "bleed" (a understandable cause) with a list of guidelines and explanations as to why they think it would help. Detractors of this method have provided hypothetical reasons to the short comings and impacts this will have for EVERYONE at the table through an attempt of mixing personal experience while cross referencing real world scenarios that have similar features. The detractors of the detractors have gone on to say that detractors of x card are wrong because hypothetically their hypothetics would never happen hypothetically they must just be bad people or atleast ignorant. EVERYONE is going off hypothetics here, because thats what happens when you try to norm a model that is not scientifically measured. If we decide to develop a new rule were if you write something in a forum causing someone distress and they can type "x" in response to you meaning you would have to change the way you are writing or just stop with the failure of doing so leading to a possible ban, based off your thousands of posts hypothetically you might be against this? You dismiss issues with nothing but hypothetics with no intention of adapting your world view.</blockquote>