Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="FrogReaver" data-source="post: 9227662" data-attributes="member: 6795602">Right.&nbsp; To some degree I think the concepts of no-myth and conflict resolution are being combined when they don't need to be.&nbsp; There's no reason I can tell that it is impossible to have myth based conflict resolution.&nbsp; I think task resolution can be played in a say yes or roll the dice way as well.&nbsp; Just set extremely high DC's for the tasks like 'flapping your arms to fly' or 'finding incriminating documents under this rock'.&nbsp; You've said yes or rolled the dice.&nbsp; But it strikes me is that maybe I'm taking that a bit too literally - it's not say yes or roll the dice, it's say yes or have a chance for success.&nbsp; Functionally though, we could change a 0% chance of success to 1 in a million success chance and we are suddenly right back in to saying yes or rolling the dice.The other things to note is that even in say yes or roll the dice, the player doesn't get to say absolutely anything - there are restrictions there, as we have all talked about before.&nbsp; Is there a fundamental difference in telling a player he can't say this thing vs telling a player that says a thing, no?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="FrogReaver, post: 9227662, member: 6795602"] Right. To some degree I think the concepts of no-myth and conflict resolution are being combined when they don't need to be. There's no reason I can tell that it is impossible to have myth based conflict resolution. I think task resolution can be played in a say yes or roll the dice way as well. Just set extremely high DC's for the tasks like 'flapping your arms to fly' or 'finding incriminating documents under this rock'. You've said yes or rolled the dice. But it strikes me is that maybe I'm taking that a bit too literally - it's not say yes or roll the dice, it's say yes or have a chance for success. Functionally though, we could change a 0% chance of success to 1 in a million success chance and we are suddenly right back in to saying yes or rolling the dice. The other things to note is that even in say yes or roll the dice, the player doesn't get to say absolutely anything - there are restrictions there, as we have all talked about before. Is there a fundamental difference in telling a player he can't say this thing vs telling a player that says a thing, no? [/QUOTE]

Verification