Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Gruns" data-source="post: 4627513" data-attributes="member: 10312">Well...I don't think anyone is really confused by this. The Effect takes on all of the keywords of the power and would be stopped by Immunity to either Arcane, Thunder, Fear or Implement. (Yes, I'm aware that two of those immunites don't exist and likely never will).Even with a power such as this where it's easy to differentiate what &quot;type&quot; an effect is:Icy ThunderEncounter - Arcane, Cold, Implement, Thunder.Ranged 10Attack: Intellegence vs FortitudeHit:&nbsp; Target takes 2d10 cold and thunder damage, is pushed 2 squares and is slowed(save ends)It'd be safe to conclude that the push effect is from the thunder and the slowed is from the cold, but since they aren't typed, immunity to cold or thunder stops both the push effect and the slow effect. (Consequently, in this case all of the damage would be stopped as well with immunity to either keyword.)No... The power is still a Thunder effect, due to the Thunder keyword. Again, this is stuff that seemingly no one is confused by.I think you're intentionally making this more confusing that it really needs to be...Later!Gruns</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Gruns, post: 4627513, member: 10312"] [b]Well...[/b] I don't think anyone is really confused by this. The Effect takes on all of the keywords of the power and would be stopped by Immunity to either Arcane, Thunder, Fear [I]or[/I] Implement. (Yes, I'm aware that two of those immunites don't exist and likely never will). Even with a power such as this where it's easy to differentiate what "type" an effect is: Icy Thunder Encounter - Arcane, Cold, Implement, Thunder. Ranged 10 Attack: Intellegence vs Fortitude Hit: Target takes 2d10 cold and thunder damage, is pushed 2 squares and is slowed(save ends) It'd be safe to conclude that the push effect is from the thunder and the slowed is from the cold, but since they aren't typed, immunity to cold [I]or[/I] thunder stops [U]both[/U] the push effect and the slow effect. (Consequently, in this case all of the damage would be stopped as well with immunity to either keyword.) No... The power is still a Thunder effect, due to the Thunder keyword. Again, this is stuff that seemingly no one is confused by. I think you're intentionally making this more confusing that it really needs to be... Later! Gruns [/QUOTE]

Verification