Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="trentonjoe" data-source="post: 665588" data-attributes="member: 304">I think your tone was unneccesarrily harsh as well there Priest.&nbsp; The poster wan't trolling, he was disagreeing.&nbsp; ANd he has a point.Maybe you should state what you want feedback on?I think much of what you posted is unclear and could be abused or at least unbalancing.The first weapon, the Falcata, as the EXACT same as a masterwork scimitar by the PHB standards but cheaper.&nbsp; Not balanced.&nbsp; If you want an elven&nbsp; masterwork scimitar to&nbsp; be called a Falcata just call it that.The second weapon is a keen longsword.&nbsp; Big deal.&nbsp; It should cost in the thousands not 425 gp.&nbsp; I would seriously adjust the price.The thickblade is okay balancewise.&nbsp; It is a slightly better longsword. Cost is probably to much. I would reccomend making it ~100gp.Here are some questions to consider, do these naturally keen weapons stack with the keen enchantment?If they are not exotic weapons for elves are they exotic for other races?If Elves gain this &quot;bonus&quot; of having these weapons being martial do they have to lose one of there PHB bonuses?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="trentonjoe, post: 665588, member: 304"] I think your tone was unneccesarrily harsh as well there Priest. The poster wan't trolling, he was disagreeing. ANd he has a point. Maybe you should state what you want feedback on? I think much of what you posted is unclear and could be abused or at least unbalancing. The first weapon, the Falcata, as the EXACT same as a masterwork scimitar by the PHB standards but cheaper. Not balanced. If you want an elven masterwork scimitar to be called a Falcata just call it that. The second weapon is a keen longsword. Big deal. It should cost in the thousands not 425 gp. I would seriously adjust the price. The thickblade is okay balancewise. It is a slightly better longsword. Cost is probably to much. I would reccomend making it ~100gp. Here are some questions to consider, do these naturally keen weapons stack with the keen enchantment? If they are not exotic weapons for elves are they exotic for other races? If Elves gain this "bonus" of having these weapons being martial do they have to lose one of there PHB bonuses? [/QUOTE]

Verification