Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="RareBreed" data-source="post: 9091135" data-attributes="member: 6945590">Sure, like I said, it's how the text is used that matters the most.  Which is why I gave the example of memorizing a play.  Perfectly fine to just have it in your head, but once you start giving performances or narrating books, then that's another story.Plagiarism and copyright violations are little more difficult to nail down.  I was just <a href="https://info.deeplearning.ai/ai-cancer-diagnosis-advances-chatbots-work-the-drive-thru-chatgpt-racks-up-server-fees-image-generators-get-an-upgrade" target="_blank">reading a post</a> from deeplearning.ai where Andrew Ng (the cofounder of cousera and the aforementioned site) often posts some ML related information.  Andrew talked about the possibility of certain models "understanding" the problem they are solving.  He starts off by saying "understanding" is as thorny of an issue as consciousness, and is more of a philosophical question, but nevertheless, he talks about some research done on Othello-GPT; an LLM trained on Othello moves...and only the moves of Othello.  In fact, the LLM wasn't even told it was learning anything about Othello.I hope more investigation and research goes into this, because if true, I think we need to look at LLM's with a different lens.I actually have an argument on the Pro-Creator side.  The problem with AI having memorized corpus of text, videos or other "information" is how easy it is to be disseminated by it.  Of course one can make the argument that the AI still needs to be connected to the internet, and that humans have this same possibility.  The problem for a human is the amount of time it would take to transfer the knowledge from brain to computer (ie, type out the text).  But, once done, would be as trivial for a human as an AI.Of course, we already have legal protections in place for humans not to do that, eg pirate material.  So I think it's a weak Pro-Creator argument, but still one that should be addressed.</blockquote>

Verification