Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Syrsuro" data-source="post: 4419064" data-attributes="member: 58162">I'd say, no.&nbsp;I see no reason to mess with the basic math.&nbsp; Because once you change that, you have to change Cleave.&nbsp; And once you change those two, you end up having to change Sure Strike (because the more additional damage you do, the less significant the bonus to hit is.)&nbsp; &nbsp;And then you start looking at the encounter abilities - because I'll bet there's a few that will look useless compared to the new Reaping Strike and Cleave.&nbsp; For example, the more damage you do on Reaping Strike, the less useful Passing Attack becomes because you have to roll to hit with Passing Attack, but Reaping Strike and Cleave are automatic.&nbsp;Etc.The point of the At-will is to make a SINGLE scaled attack, with a small benefit to make it better than your basic melee.&nbsp; Not to make two scaled attacks.&nbsp; If you want to make multiple scaled attacks, that would be an Encounter ability.&nbsp;Carl</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Syrsuro, post: 4419064, member: 58162"] I'd say, no. I see no reason to mess with the basic math. Because once you change that, you have to change Cleave. And once you change those two, you end up having to change Sure Strike (because the more additional damage you do, the less significant the bonus to hit is.) And then you start looking at the encounter abilities - because I'll bet there's a few that will look useless compared to the new Reaping Strike and Cleave. For example, the more damage you do on Reaping Strike, the less useful Passing Attack becomes because you have to roll to [I]hit[/I] with Passing Attack, but Reaping Strike and Cleave are automatic. Etc. The point of the At-will is to make a SINGLE scaled attack, with a small benefit to make it better than your basic melee. Not to make two scaled attacks. If you want to make multiple scaled attacks, that would be an Encounter ability. Carl [/QUOTE]

Verification