Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="howandwhy99" data-source="post: 3420955" data-attributes="member: 3192">I'd say most now believe it is against the rules, yes.  If your PC is described as performing an action only possible when incorporated with another mechanic, your breaking the RAW.  If you can remember what effects are not covered by rules, go ahead and use those for descripton.  However, the DM might correct you regardless.IMO, this is a system failure.  Description now has zero effect on the game unless it is tied to a mechanic.  Many people prefer this style of game, where 1000's of rules (feats, etc.) are offered and you pick the ones you like.  I prefer the older D&D editions where description actually influenced the game, even if the player only rolled a single d20.  It's all personal preference.  In our OD&D game, description dictates reality in a nearly unlimited number of possible ways.</blockquote>