Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="clearstream" data-source="post: 8741214" data-attributes="member: 71699">IKR! Others keep revisiting it.As I hopefully made pretty clear up-thread, I took no issue at all with gaining 1s for investing the resource. That 1s can be granted regardless of the number on the Nature check, as the check for the ritual determines the ritual's effectiveness, not whether it succeeds. (It determines Overland Flight speed.) You tied it to the number rolled, which can be parsed under the rules to mean one of two things<ul>
<li data-xf-list-type="ul">You wanted to see an Overland Flight of above a certain speed (15+) to get that 1s</li>
<li data-xf-list-type="ul">You wanted a hard Nature check anyway, and using Eagles' Flight was granting an auto-1s</li>
</ul>(Seeing as you called for one roll, it seems it must be the latter, right?)What I queried in the first instance was whether you intended to grant +1s for Nature check as primary or secondary skill use, which is covered by a specific rule (advantages for complexity 3+ challenges). Conceivably, in that case one would be granting an ongoing +1s (where Nature was allowed to contribute more than once to the SC.) You clarified - as I understood your later post - that you did not intend that. Which made sense to me as that chimes better with the rules on advantages for complexity 3+ SCs. Phewf.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="clearstream, post: 8741214, member: 71699"] IKR! Others keep revisiting it. As I hopefully made pretty clear up-thread, I took no issue at all with gaining 1s for investing the resource. That 1s can be granted [I]regardless [/I]of the number on the Nature check, as the check for the ritual determines the ritual's [I]effectiveness[/I], not whether it succeeds. (It determines Overland Flight speed.) You tied it to the number rolled, which can be parsed under the rules to mean one of two things [LIST] [*]You wanted to see an Overland Flight of above a certain speed (15+) to get that 1s [*]You wanted a hard Nature check anyway, and using Eagles' Flight was granting an auto-1s [/LIST] (Seeing as you called for one roll, it seems it must be the latter, right?) What I queried in the first instance was whether you intended to grant +1s for Nature check as primary or secondary skill use, which is covered by a specific rule (advantages for complexity 3+ challenges). Conceivably, in that case one would be granting an ongoing +1s (where Nature was allowed to contribute more than once to the SC.) You clarified - as I understood your later post - that you did [I]not [/I]intend that. Which made sense to me as that chimes better with the rules on advantages for complexity 3+ SCs. Phewf. [/QUOTE]

Verification