Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hawken" data-source="post: 4347281" data-attributes="member: 23619">I get that it wouldn't grant SA with the splash. But I just don't see how it could grant SA anyway. SA is precision based damage. The rogue is targeting a precise spot on the target, hitting a specific organ or nerve, something. He might be able to hit the spot on the target he wants where the bottle breaks, but he has absolutely no control over where/how the contents splash and hit the target once the container breaks. One could argue that the SA represents getting the contents in the target's eyes or ears or mouth. However, you don't need SA to do that. The higher end of the damage die seems to represent that happening. Game mechanics, sure, I can see allowing it since the rules don't forbid it, but neither do they overtly support it either. I want to give my player a fair shake, so I'm here doing my &quot;research&quot; on this. What do you other DMs think about this? How would you rule on this?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hawken, post: 4347281, member: 23619"] I get that it wouldn't grant SA with the splash. But I just don't see how it could grant SA anyway. SA is precision based damage. The rogue is targeting a precise spot on the target, hitting a specific organ or nerve, something. He might be able to hit the spot on the target he wants where the bottle breaks, but he has absolutely no control over where/how the contents splash and hit the target once the container breaks. One could argue that the SA represents getting the contents in the target's eyes or ears or mouth. However, you don't need SA to do that. The higher end of the damage die seems to represent that happening. Game mechanics, sure, I can see allowing it since the rules don't forbid it, but neither do they overtly support it either. I want to give my player a fair shake, so I'm here doing my "research" on this. What do you other DMs think about this? How would you rule on this? [/QUOTE]

Verification