Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="AaronOfBarbaria" data-source="post: 6844914" data-attributes="member: 6701872">Really? That's... very strange to not let a player say what they want their character to say without some kind of approval first.Who said "make a star" was a riddle solution? I certainly didn't. I only said it is what one player had his character say, and the time at which that happened in our game play.Are you saying that if I know what a character has been made to say on a whim is actually correct and the player knows it, I should behave differently as a DM than I would if I believed the player in that situation had no clue that what they had said was even relevant, let alone correct?I am seeing a double-standard here; The player of the high INT character you describe above "ultimately controls his actions", but you have stated that the player of the interrupting character I described in my scenario is not afforded that same control of his characters actions.Why have you made that the case? Have you made an assumption of what the character in my scenario has for an INT score? If yes, can you say exactly what you assume the score to be, and what score it would have to be the for the player to ultimately control his character's actions?Also, I now feel that you really haven't actually addressed the questions asked in my posted scenario - we've just started a side discussion about other things. I'd like it if you could pop back to post #708 and give a response to the questions asked there.</blockquote>

Verification