Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Ovinomancer" data-source="post: 6845434" data-attributes="member: 16814">Then it was my bad for assuming that.  Given many such postulations wherein the example behavior was the solution to the puzzle, I, understandably, confused your intent.Do you have a set of breakpoints in a list of when something moves from this to that next to you when you run, or do you make judgement calls based on the wealth of additional information in the situation that isn't present in your thumbnail sketch?  I've already been in trouble for assuming additional information (which I clearly stated) because it wasn't your additional information, so my answer to your question of 'when does it cross the line' is that you haven't provided enough information for me to tell you.  It's highly dependent on a number of factors that you haven't presented.I rather assumed that such knowledge would be available to the DM, not a surprise to them, so I didn't even consider that something that needed answering.  If you insist, yes, if I did not know what the characters in my game where capable of, I would have to ask so that I did know.  As for the portrayal being fine or not, I don't know -- you don't provide an example of a portrayal of a character, you provided a thumbnail sketch of events at the table with no information on how anyone in the sketch 'portrayed' their character.  It may be fine, it may not, there's not enough information in your sketch for me to hazard a guess without assuming things you didn't provide.</blockquote>

Verification