Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="pemerton" data-source="post: 6297540" data-attributes="member: 42582">Here is ForeverSlayer arguing that Boundless Endurance must be magic, because it involves the regeneration of tissue:Here is Wicht stating that, in PF, regeneration and fast healing mean the regeneration of tissue:And here is Paizo, in Ultimate Combat, stating that a barbarian can gain fast healing as an EX (= non-magical) ability:At least one of [MENTION=91812]ForeverSlayer[/MENTION], Wicht and Paizo must be wrong:<ul>
<li data-xf-list-type="ul">If Paizo and Wicht are both correct, then ForeverSlayer is wrong to thing that the ability to rapidly knit together tissue is magic; 
 
</li>
<li data-xf-list-type="ul">If Paizo and ForeverSlayer are both correct, then given that rapidly knitting together tissue is magical, and given that there is a non-magical fast healing ability with the word &quot;regenerative&quot; in its name, then Wicht is wrong to think that fast healing and regeneration in PF have any general connotation of knitting together tissue (and is wrong also to think that Regenerative Vigour involves knitting together of tissue); 
 
</li>
<li data-xf-list-type="ul">If ForeverSlayer and Wicht are both correct, then Paizo was wrong to label a fast healing power EX - it should be SU.</li>
</ul>Is anyone able to tell me who it is who is wrong?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="pemerton, post: 6297540, member: 42582"] Here is ForeverSlayer arguing that Boundless Endurance must be magic, because it involves the regeneration of tissue: Here is Wicht stating that, in PF, regeneration and fast healing mean the regeneration of tissue: And here is Paizo, in Ultimate Combat, stating that a barbarian can gain fast healing as an EX (= non-magical) ability: At least one of [MENTION=91812]ForeverSlayer[/MENTION], Wicht and Paizo must be wrong: [list][*]If Paizo and Wicht are both correct, then ForeverSlayer is wrong to thing that the ability to rapidly knit together tissue is magic; [*]If Paizo and ForeverSlayer are both correct, then given that rapidly knitting together tissue is magical, and given that there is a non-magical fast healing ability with the word "regenerative" in its name, then Wicht is wrong to think that fast healing and regeneration in PF have any general connotation of knitting together tissue (and is wrong also to think that Regenerative Vigour involves knitting together of tissue); [*]If ForeverSlayer and Wicht are both correct, then Paizo was wrong to label a fast healing power EX - it should be SU.[/LIST] Is anyone able to tell me who it is who is wrong? [/QUOTE]

Verification