Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="BryonD" data-source="post: 6559605" data-attributes="member: 957">I agree with all of these.&nbsp; But the conversation is going in a circle.The point I was responding to was the idea that the success of D&amp;D (as an RPG) is not important.If we assume there are people spending &quot;a lot of money on it&quot; then we are no longer assuming its success is not present.&nbsp; And if you are assuring potential partners of this, you are assuring them of &quot;success&quot;.So this option does not meet the criteria of the question.If we assume it is simply because core books are where the profit lives, then cool.&nbsp; But this makes no sense with the whole &quot;two APs and nothing else for as far as the eye can see&quot; approach.&nbsp; So that option does not meet the criteria of the question.Reunification works.&nbsp; But I don't see how fleeting reunification really helps if they don't fight to maintain the fan base once it is reunified.So, I agree with all three of these points.&nbsp; But the strategy being advertised does not advance the agendas.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="BryonD, post: 6559605, member: 957"] I agree with all of these. But the conversation is going in a circle. The point I was responding to was the idea that the success of D&D (as an RPG) is not important. If we assume there are people spending "a lot of money on it" then we are no longer assuming its success is not present. And if you are assuring potential partners of this, you are assuring them of "success". So this option does not meet the criteria of the question. If we assume it is simply because core books are where the profit lives, then cool. But this makes no sense with the whole "two APs and nothing else for as far as the eye can see" approach. So that option does not meet the criteria of the question. Reunification works. But I don't see how fleeting reunification really helps if they don't fight to maintain the fan base once it is reunified. So, I agree with all three of these points. But the strategy being advertised does not advance the agendas. [/QUOTE]

Verification