Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="RotGrub" data-source="post: 6661010" data-attributes="member: 6777078">It's not useless.&nbsp; The fighter is not always fighting creatures with more HD than himself.&nbsp; In most cases they are the same HD or lower.&nbsp;&nbsp; Can a 7th level fighter in 4e kill a troll in one round?&nbsp; So let me get this right, you want to take that power away from the fighter (all those extra attacks) and give him authorship powers that keep that troll alive much longer?&nbsp; Btw, your example stinks because your forgetting about all those levels above 7th (ie. level 12 vs 12 HD).&nbsp; Your also forgetting that in 2e there is very little correlation to a monsters AC and its HD.&nbsp; A Will o'wisp for example has an AC of -8 and only 9HD.&nbsp; what rule is that?&nbsp;&nbsp; Never read a rule like that in 2e.I'm still not understanding why player authorship/agency is required to make the fighter more powerful.&nbsp; </blockquote>

[QUOTE="RotGrub, post: 6661010, member: 6777078"] It's not useless. The fighter is not always fighting creatures with more HD than himself. In most cases they are the same HD or lower. Can a 7th level fighter in 4e kill a troll in one round? So let me get this right, you want to take that power away from the fighter (all those extra attacks) and give him authorship powers that keep that troll alive much longer? Btw, your example stinks because your forgetting about all those levels above 7th (ie. level 12 vs 12 HD). Your also forgetting that in 2e there is very little correlation to a monsters AC and its HD. A Will o'wisp for example has an AC of -8 and only 9HD. what rule is that? Never read a rule like that in 2e. [COLOR=#333333][FONT=Verdana]I'm still not understanding why player authorship/agency is required to make the fighter more powerful. [/FONT][/COLOR] [/QUOTE]

Verification