Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="BryonD" data-source="post: 5189169" data-attributes="member: 957">You haven't answered the question, you have simply invented a different and incorrect alternative circumstance.Your description substitutes &quot;the spell stops being effective&quot; in place of &quot;the spell ends&quot;.&nbsp; When you attack, you don't become visible because the targets blood shows you or because somehow every possible observer gains a magic ability to pinpoint fireball origin points.&nbsp; You become visible because the spell ends.&nbsp; NOTHING is invisible anymore.&nbsp; But even with that, your solution just shuffles the problem.&nbsp; What if you are in a necromancer's lair sneaking invisibly around.&nbsp; You need to know if a zombie is hiding in a vat of blood.&nbsp; So you poke your sword around in the vat.&nbsp; Why is this blood not giving you away?&nbsp; A Thermos does not react to hot or cold.&nbsp; Invisible reacts to an attack.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="BryonD, post: 5189169, member: 957"] You haven't answered the question, you have simply invented a different and incorrect alternative circumstance. Your description substitutes "the spell stops being effective" in place of "the spell ends". When you attack, you don't become visible because the targets blood shows you or because somehow every possible observer gains a magic ability to pinpoint fireball origin points. You become visible because the spell ends. NOTHING is invisible anymore. But even with that, your solution just shuffles the problem. What if you are in a necromancer's lair sneaking invisibly around. You need to know if a zombie is hiding in a vat of blood. So you poke your sword around in the vat. Why is this blood not giving you away? A Thermos does not react to hot or cold. Invisible reacts to an attack. [/QUOTE]

Verification