Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Twowolves" data-source="post: 4948290" data-attributes="member: 18093">I'd say unattended noisy items do, yeah. Of course, if a +1 shield were silenced.. who'd notice? Again, I think the spell is worded as it is because of weird stand-alone magical noisemakers.I never understood why Silence is an Illusion(Glammer). It really should be Transmutation, IMO. *goes to check is 1st ed PHB*In fact, it was Alteration back in 1st ed. And it used to specify &quot;No save&quot; in the spell block, and state in the description that if you tried to stick the emanation the target did get a save. Making the save centered the effect 1 foot behind the intended target.And oddly enough, the name of the spell was &quot;Silence, 15' Radius&quot; but the effect line in the stat block said &quot;30' Diameter Sphere&quot;.... <img src="http://www.enworld.org/forum/images/smilies/erm.png"&nbsp; class="smilie" loading="lazy" alt=":erm:" title="Erm&nbsp; &nbsp; :erm:" data-shortname=":erm:" /></blockquote>

[QUOTE="Twowolves, post: 4948290, member: 18093"] I'd say unattended [I]noisy [/I]items do, yeah. Of course, if a +1 shield were silenced.. who'd notice? Again, I think the spell is worded as it is because of weird stand-alone magical noisemakers. I never understood why Silence is an Illusion(Glammer). It really should be Transmutation, IMO. *goes to check is 1st ed PHB* In fact, it was Alteration back in 1st ed. And it used to specify "No save" in the spell block, and state in the description that if you tried to stick the emanation the target did get a save. Making the save centered the effect 1 foot behind the intended target. And oddly enough, the name of the spell was "Silence, 15' Radius" but the effect line in the stat block said "30' Diameter Sphere".... :erm: [/QUOTE]

Verification