Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="jdavis" data-source="post: 624113" data-attributes="member: 8704">Jackson has a real fine line to walk with what he does in the movies and he will not please everybody. I do not have a problem at all with the love story (of course I thought he should dump her and go with Eowin when I read the book). I think it will be just as dramatic a scene to start off ROTK with her showing up at Isengard with Narsil instead of leaving Middle Earth, not to mention it fufills the role of getting the sword there without having to introduce more bit characters. It fits the time in the books better than her showing up at Helm's Deep, they already had a Elves showing up at Helm's Deep scene, two of them might of seemed a little much. And yes I'm sure alot of people would of been mad if she showed up, that's just too big a departure from the books for plot development that can be done a little later and still fit the basic timeline of the books. Edit: moved part of what I wrote to the ROTK thread where it makes more sense.</blockquote>