Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="ashockney" data-source="post: 604883" data-attributes="member: 1363">FeedbackI'm assuming you put this here for feedback, if not, please diregard all of my comments.&nbsp;Cool idea.&nbsp; In execution, however, without the spells, the only advantage here is that you're only getting this advantage for relevant skills and the damage bonus.&nbsp; &nbsp;Another really cool idea. This goes too far.&nbsp; I could see doing offense and defense against the same favored enemy, however, the bonuses could get way too high.&nbsp; I've got a Monk with Wis bonus to damage from my last campaign and by high levels he was routinely looking at a +7 to +10 in this stat.&nbsp; If you tripled this number it would be too far out of balance with comparable effects.&nbsp; Granted it's only one type of creature, but that makes you as the DM not want to put any of these into the encounter because your ranger will be mowing them down.I like your ideas, in general, for favored terrain.&nbsp; I'd rather see &quot;Perception&quot; as a flat bonus to spot and listen and WL checks.&nbsp; Your current wording leaves a lot in the hands of the &quot;DM&quot; instead of giving something to the PC.Tremorsense is a kickass idea for rangers.&nbsp; I love it.&nbsp; Nature's Call is ok, but why not just give them animal companions?Bonus Feats, d8 hp, good skills, and good fort and ref saves help to round out the class.&nbsp; I think this one would be fun to play, and distinctive from the other party &quot;fighter&quot; types.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="ashockney, post: 604883, member: 1363"] [b]Feedback[/b] I'm assuming you put this here for feedback, if not, please diregard all of my comments. Cool idea. In execution, however, without the spells, the only advantage here is that you're only getting this advantage for relevant skills and the damage bonus. Another really cool idea. This goes too far. I could see doing offense and defense against the same favored enemy, however, the bonuses could get way too high. I've got a Monk with Wis bonus to damage from my last campaign and by high levels he was routinely looking at a +7 to +10 in this stat. If you tripled this number it would be too far out of balance with comparable effects. Granted it's only one type of creature, but that makes you as the DM not want to put any of these into the encounter because your ranger will be mowing them down. I like your ideas, in general, for favored terrain. I'd rather see "Perception" as a flat bonus to spot and listen and WL checks. Your current wording leaves a lot in the hands of the "DM" instead of giving something to the PC. Tremorsense is a kickass idea for rangers. I love it. Nature's Call is ok, but why not just give them animal companions? Bonus Feats, d8 hp, good skills, and good fort and ref saves help to round out the class. I think this one would be fun to play, and distinctive from the other party "fighter" types. [/QUOTE]

Verification