Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="gonesailing" data-source="post: 4289969" data-attributes="member: 16426">Overall I like it.&nbsp; I like that it is pretty easy to create a Skill challenge with it and if the math works out that it is intuitive that is fantastic!!&nbsp; Some questions and then some comments:1 - How will this combine with Combat Encounters do you think.&nbsp; Will a Level 3-4 Skill Challenge be a replacement for a level 4 monster?2 - XP awards are unmentioned in your synopsis.&nbsp; See above question?3 - Your target percentage is 80% Party Win Rate from what I see. What effect will +/- 1 or 2 to the DCs do to the Party Win Rate?4 - What effect will DM awards of +/- 2 have on the mechanic?&nbsp; For plus I would think it would be equivalent to Aid another, but what if it is on top of Aid.Now for the comments:I think the presentation of the System still leaves a little to be desired.&nbsp; But you did most of the Hard work, so let one of us take a crack at that.It needs Playtesting!Your Skill Challenge example doesn't really highlight the system.&nbsp; Try this one and give me your opinionsEdit...Oops wrong attachment.&nbsp; I will fix it tommorrow when I get to work. This is just the template I made for myself</blockquote>

[QUOTE="gonesailing, post: 4289969, member: 16426"] Overall I like it. I like that it is pretty easy to create a Skill challenge with it and if the math works out that it is intuitive that is fantastic!! Some questions and then some comments: 1 - How will this combine with Combat Encounters do you think. Will a Level 3-4 Skill Challenge be a replacement for a level 4 monster? 2 - XP awards are unmentioned in your synopsis. See above question? 3 - Your target percentage is 80% Party Win Rate from what I see. What effect will +/- 1 or 2 to the DCs do to the Party Win Rate? 4 - What effect will DM awards of +/- 2 have on the mechanic? For plus I would think it would be equivalent to Aid another, but what if it is on top of Aid. Now for the comments: I think the presentation of the System still leaves a little to be desired. But you did most of the Hard work, so let one of us take a crack at that. It needs Playtesting! Your Skill Challenge example doesn't really highlight the system. Try this one and give me your opinions Edit...Oops wrong attachment. I will fix it tommorrow when I get to work. This is just the template I made for myself [/QUOTE]

Verification