Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Ruin Explorer" data-source="post: 9370740" data-attributes="member: 18">Why don't you specifically name what you consider "well-written" here? I suspect you're trying to avoid putting a list of stuff you like because of vibes, but which is highly open to criticism.I can't think of a single "well-written" Star Wars game since KotOR2, for example. Jedi Fallen Order and Survivor have, at best, extremely mid-to-bad writing, for example.Movies I suspect you're going for Rogue One, but the writing there is pretty bad, despite Tony Gilroy being airdropped in to try and rescue it. Fundamentally Gary Whitta can't write for toffee, and that's never changed - he's just inexplicably got an "in" at Hollywood despite his repeated direly-written movies.Also love to hear which SW novels you're thinking are "well-written".You claiming that Leslye "Russian Doll" Headland isn't the "A, B or C team", which is a staggeringly nasty claim, means you kind of need to answer this, because otherwise your credibility is like, literally negative - i.e. what you're saying should be seen as actively wrong, what you're endorsing should be seen as actively bad. You need to justify your position with specific examples, I would suggest, or admit you have no position except vibes.</blockquote>