Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Infiniti2000" data-source="post: 2777031" data-attributes="member: 31734">You may not know success or failure, but you can certainly judge whether you did well or not, giving your own knowledge of your capabilities.&nbsp; Translated: if you roll a 1, you know did badly and can choose (in game, in character) to try again.&nbsp; The ability specifically allows you the use of this metagame data.&nbsp;As much as you want it to be superfluous, it's not.&nbsp; If you want to know how UMD works, you look in UMD.&nbsp; When you use UMD for a scroll, you look in both UMD and the sections on scrolls.&nbsp; You have an inherently flawed approach to understanding the D&amp;D/d20 rules.&nbsp;Of course it's part of an action.&nbsp; That was obvious to everyone from the fact that I called it a non-action.&nbsp; Your disagreement that Move Silently is a non-action is completely without merit.&nbsp;Once again, that's not provable.&nbsp; You may play it that way, but that's not a rule in the game.&nbsp; Do you have anything to prove this statement?&nbsp; Can you provide the definition of an &quot;in-game event&quot;?Storm Raven, do you have anything useful to contribute to this (or any) thread?&nbsp; It seems like your entire purpose in this forum is to start a fight.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Infiniti2000, post: 2777031, member: 31734"] You may not know success or failure, but you can certainly judge whether you did well or not, giving your own knowledge of your capabilities. Translated: if you roll a 1, you know did badly and can choose (in game, in character) to try again. The ability specifically allows you the use of this metagame data. As much as you want it to be superfluous, it's not. If you want to know how UMD works, you look in UMD. When you use UMD for a scroll, you look in [B]both[/B] UMD and the section[U]s[/U] on scrolls. You have an inherently flawed approach to understanding the D&D/d20 rules. Of course it's part of an action. That was obvious to everyone from the fact that I called it a non-action. Your disagreement that Move Silently is a non-action is completely without merit. Once again, that's not provable. You may play it that way, but that's not a rule in the game. Do you have anything to prove this statement? Can you provide the definition of an "in-game event"? Storm Raven, do you have anything useful to contribute to this (or any) thread? It seems like your entire purpose in this forum is to start a fight. [/QUOTE]

Verification