Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 4392039" data-attributes="member: 2525">For the point on intelligent creatures...lets be very clear: Your personal system does not follow that &quot;rules as intended&quot;.&nbsp; It's not there.&nbsp; If you think that is RAI, then why doesn't your system have it?As for communicating, you still need to actually do the communication, which has limits on it, and you are not accounting for those limits in your &quot;system&quot;.&nbsp; You make it automatic communication at all times, but that is not what Mearls said.&nbsp; It's no more the case that all creatures always communicate everything at all times as it is that all creatures are always using stealth at all times.&nbsp; Some creatures will do it, others will not, and sometimes will depend on the situation at hand, and it's in no way automatic.&nbsp; Your system doesn't work the way that Mearls is describing it - you make it always on, always automatic, always successful.&nbsp;&nbsp; As for rehiding, so let me see if I get this straight...for rehiding, you will default to RAW over what you claim is RAI, but for going against each creatures perception check instead of all of them at once, you go with what you think is RAI instead of RAW?I think it's time you just fessed up that this is just all your personal system.&nbsp; It's a fine system, but you know, I know, and pretty much everyone in this thread knows it's not the known rules as intended.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mistwell, post: 4392039, member: 2525"] For the point on intelligent creatures...lets be very clear: Your personal system does not follow that "rules as intended". It's not there. If you think that is RAI, then why doesn't your system have it? As for communicating, you still need to actually do the communication, which has limits on it, and you are not accounting for those limits in your "system". You make it automatic communication at all times, but that is not what Mearls said. It's no more the case that all creatures always communicate everything at all times as it is that all creatures are always using stealth at all times. Some creatures will do it, others will not, and sometimes will depend on the situation at hand, and it's in no way automatic. Your system doesn't work the way that Mearls is describing it - you make it always on, always automatic, always successful. As for rehiding, so let me see if I get this straight...for rehiding, you will default to RAW over what you claim is RAI, but for going against each creatures perception check instead of all of them at once, you go with what you think is RAI instead of RAW? I think it's time you just fessed up that this is just all your personal system. It's a fine system, but you know, I know, and pretty much everyone in this thread knows it's not the known rules as intended. [/QUOTE]

Verification