Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Vocenoctum" data-source="post: 3017730" data-attributes="member: 2477">I think 9 Swords and MM4 are too new (and the revile too fresh) for them to be accurately judged.I'd also have to say COmplete Divine really. A LOT of folks are down on it because the PrC's are eh, and the editing of them worse. BUT, where CD shines is the extra stuff, there's a lot of stuff that was cool to read. (Even if the Hooked Hammer picture is missing half...)Sure, the PrC's are better in Complete Arcane &amp; Warrior, but the material in CD is cool.The books that I think are unfairly criticized are the books such as Dieties &amp; Demigods, where WotC said &quot;this book will be X&quot;, but people expected Y, and then complained when they bought the book and it was X.Same with MM4, the complaints are not about the quality within the chosen format, but about the chosen format, so it's sort of irksome.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Vocenoctum, post: 3017730, member: 2477"] I think 9 Swords and MM4 are too new (and the revile too fresh) for them to be accurately judged. I'd also have to say COmplete Divine really. A LOT of folks are down on it because the PrC's are eh, and the editing of them worse. BUT, where CD shines is the extra stuff, there's a lot of stuff that was cool to read. (Even if the Hooked Hammer picture is missing half...) Sure, the PrC's are better in Complete Arcane & Warrior, but the material in CD is cool. The books that I think are unfairly criticized are the books such as Dieties & Demigods, where WotC said "this book will be X", but people expected Y, and then complained when they bought the book and it was X. Same with MM4, the complaints are not about the quality within the chosen format, but about the chosen format, so it's sort of irksome. [/QUOTE]

Verification