Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="JamesonCourage" data-source="post: 6588923" data-attributes="member: 6668292">Based on your comments, I don't think you do.Because it's wrong.If you get to state your opinion on what I'm doing, I get to state my opinion on what you're doing.Okay?Yep. That is a perfectly good way of doing it. These are things I consider often when I'm running various games. And it's perfectly fine to have fun this way in any edition of D&amp;D. I don't see the objection?If your players like the rails, then there's no problem. I don't get it. I'm not painting that style as bad, I'm saying I don't engage in it with my RPG campaign, even if you think I do. That's all. Of course people have fun with the style you're describing.Yeah, feel free to do that. I'm not saying not to do that. You know that, right?I know you don't.Okay. Your views on this topic are a little more clear. I don't have anything to say about them (as they don't tie into how you've painted my play style), but okay.I can do that.Based on how you express yourself, yes, clearly I think that.There's no need to paint it in another light, either. Or describe it in a way that it isn't, and then go on about how that's not effective (I think the kids call that strawmanning?). But if you continue to talk about a gaming philosophy I engage in, I'll probably participate. If it gets attacked, I'll probably defend it. How else would I act on a discussion board?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="JamesonCourage, post: 6588923, member: 6668292"] Based on your comments, I don't think you do. Because it's wrong. If you get to state your opinion on what I'm doing, I get to state my opinion on what you're doing. Okay? Yep. That is a perfectly good way of doing it. These are things I consider often when I'm running various games. And it's perfectly fine to have fun this way in any edition of D&D. I don't see the objection? If your players like the rails, then there's no problem. I don't get it. I'm not painting that style as bad, I'm saying I don't engage in it with my RPG campaign, even if you think I do. That's all. Of course people have fun with the style you're describing. Yeah, feel free to do that. I'm not saying not to do that. You know that, right? I know you don't. Okay. Your views on this topic are a little more clear. I don't have anything to say about them (as they don't tie into how you've painted my play style), but okay. I can do that. Based on how you express yourself, yes, clearly I think that. There's no need to paint it in another light, either. Or describe it in a way that it isn't, and then go on about how that's not effective (I think the kids call that strawmanning?). But if you continue to talk about a gaming philosophy I engage in, I'll probably participate. If it gets attacked, I'll probably defend it. How else would I act on a discussion board? [/QUOTE]

Verification