Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Greg K" data-source="post: 3996960" data-attributes="member: 5038">I wish I could say that I was surprised to see PHB2 rate higher than either Complete Arcane and Complete Warrior, but I am not.&nbsp; I thought it had a few good things to offer (the druid shapeshift variant, the fighter ability variants, a few worthwhile feats and the polymorph spells), but was&nbsp; merely above average and I become less impressed with the book the more that I look at it. The big surprise for me was the rating for Complete Adventurer which I thought was completely mediocre at best. The best thing it had to offer, imo, being the expanded skills with only a few of the actual spells, feats, and PRC being any decent (sorry, I dislike the Scout with its skirmish and consider ithe class to be vastly overrated).&nbsp; However, given that I thought the majority of the race and class books were dismal, I expected the book to finish 5th to 6th (behind Complete Arcane, Complete Warrior, Heroes of Horror, PHB2 and possibly Complete Mage).</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Greg K, post: 3996960, member: 5038"] I wish I could say that I was surprised to see PHB2 rate higher than either Complete Arcane and Complete Warrior, but I am not. I thought it had a few good things to offer (the druid shapeshift variant, the fighter ability variants, a few worthwhile feats and the polymorph spells), but was merely above average and I become less impressed with the book the more that I look at it. The big surprise for me was the rating for Complete Adventurer which I thought was completely mediocre at best. The best thing it had to offer, imo, being the expanded skills with only a few of the actual spells, feats, and PRC being any decent (sorry, I dislike the Scout with its skirmish and consider ithe class to be vastly overrated). However, given that I thought the majority of the race and class books were dismal, I expected the book to finish 5th to 6th (behind Complete Arcane, Complete Warrior, Heroes of Horror, PHB2 and possibly Complete Mage). [/QUOTE]

Verification