Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Jack7" data-source="post: 4954105" data-attributes="member: 54707">ESSAYS ON GAME DESIGNEssay Twelve: The Blood of Uncanny Monsters*“The Blood of the monster is the doom of the unwary.”“He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss gazes also into you.”“Fantasy, abandoned by reason, produces impossible monsters; united with it, she is the mother of the arts and the origin of marvels.”“History is not the story of heroes entirely. It is often the story of cruelty and injustice and shortsightedness. There are monsters, there is evil...”“… I prefer the monsters of my fancy to what is positively trivial.”Synopsis: The Blood of Monsters is far more than the blood of simple animals, or the nerveless sap of tree limbs. The blood of the monster is a deep, potent, ancient, terrible thing, capable of warping the world, and either wondrously enabling, or viciously crippling and killing, the Hero. Beware the blood of the monster, and do not easily discard the tremendous potential it encloses within itself.Essay: In myth it is often the case that the blood, tissues, organs, or parts of a monster have unique, if not astounding properties of their own, quite apart from those possessed by the whole or intact, living creature itself.Yet far too often these additional (or inherent really) “monstrous characteristics” are overlooked (sometimes entirely) in fantasy, mythological, and magical gaming. Monsters are slain, their blood washes over the characters to no real effect, and the monstrous bodies or corpses thereafter simply discarded, as if they were the inconvenient, tiresome, or useless detritus of the true business of adventuring. No real consequences ensue from, or for, the slaying of monsters, from being in close proximity to them when they are killed, or from being washed and covered in the gore and curses and hatred and pollution and ferocity of their ultimate demise. The death of monsters becomes a mere mathematical and mechanical expression of character survival beyond beastly endurance, rather than a fascinating cosmic struggle between weird and uncanny physical, supernatural, and magical forces and the life-force of men. And the killing of monsters likewise has either no additional benefit, nor any additional consequence, other than the taking of their treasure or the removal of their objection to whatever goal(s) the hero currently or ultimately pursues. In short the monster is far less a real monster, far less a real threat, far less weird and far less dangerous, than if hunting and killing monsters implied nothing more mysterious, fantastic, and potentially lethal than a mere exercise in hit point reduction to “less than zero.” As a matter of fact killing most monsters in many role play games implies a level of danger and consequence that is exactly that, less than zero. Once slain or nearly slain a monster is then no more of a real threat than the paper-tiger number stats used to summarize his imaginary existence. But is this really a proper expression of the idea of monstrousness? In the imagination? In myth? Or even in-game?Certainly not so in myth, where the blood of monsters and weird beings often has dramatic (and even sometimes life-long) effects upon the heroes who encounter such marvels, perhaps even upon nearby observers, other monsters, or the very landscape itself. In this respect I think myth is often far more engaging, richer in content and implication, tremendously more interesting, and far more versatile than typical fantasy (or other genres of) role play gaming. Monsters actually mean things in myth. They are not simply the enemy soldier du jour, dressed in some fantastic garb of hoary yet impotent flesh or rotting, undead sheets of nothingness. They are not merely “tactical challenges” as would be the case as if an infantry battalion in a wargame were suddenly compressed into a single fearsome body and sent forth to fight tooth and claw against armed adventurers. Instead monsters are “danger incarnate,” they are a warping of the woof of existence, their being alters and changes things around them, they bend reality, sicken or extend it, they reshape nature (physical, mental, and spiritual) into a monstrosity of devastating potential. In myth (from which spring the sources of the idea and shapes and names and forms of monsters in role play games) monsters are dangerous, deadly, uncanny, they distort the nature of the things they encounter, and they do all of this both within and well-beyond the very narrow confines of combat. It seems to me then that the monster should be returned to his more natural (or unnatural, depending upon your point of view) state(s) of being, a being that exudes, reflects and engenders corruption, weirdness, lethality, and real, unremitting and unrepentant peril. Both in life, and in death. * In short I am advocating the idea that even the blood, tissues, and corpses of monsters might very well, and even in some cases definitely should, have effects both upon the characters encountering them, and upon the entire atmosphere and environment of the role-play milieu. That monsters become far more than mere combat automatons, far more than just tactical challenges, far more than an enemy in a rubber mask and a plastic suit of armor who can execute feats of multiple backflips or shoot acid from a naphtha gland in his mouth. Monsters are not simply monsters because they look weird, because men find them to be distasteful, evil, ugly, frightening, gigantic, or unique adversaries. Monsters are also monsters because of their peculiarly monstrous qualities, which extend far beyond motive and appearance and down to the very marrow of their bones, as well as throughout the blood or ichor that washes unseen through their twisted veins. And that when this blood (and/or body) becomes exposed to the world at large, when it stains the flesh of the hero, and when the bones of monsters litter the landscape, other things occur of definite and noticeable effect. Things that are sometimes wondrous, things that are sometimes terrible, occasionally even more horrifying in implication or outcome than the threat of the original monster itself. (I use the term monster in this respect in a very generalized sense. Of course the same “monstrous properties” might be said to exist for supernatural beings and alien creatures, in horror/supernatural/adventure/superhero, and sci-fi gaming. And I would hardly argue against the same types of monstrous properties I am advocating for mythological and fantasy based monsters is such cases. Rather I would just expect that given the nature of the creature in question that such properties would manifest differently, but also quite obviously, in those other types of circumstances.)With that in mind I am going to suggest some effects that will result from the injury, death, or shedding of the blood of uncanny monsters. Some of these effects will be light, some dramatic, some wondrous, and some terrible. Feel free to add your own ideas. This is an <a href="http://www.enworld.org/forum/blogs/jack7/1776-interactive-essay.html" target="_blank">Interactive Essay</a> on the notion of “Monstrosity.”The Corpus Dejecti: First of all, let me speak about the remains or parts of a monster’s body (whether or not the creature itself has survived as a result of loss of these assets). The remains or parts of a monster are valuable because of the unique properties they bestow both upon the monster itself, and anyone else either fortunate enough, or unfortunate enough, to gain control of or contact such remains. To that end let me detail just some of the possible parts of a monster’s body that could be invaluable, a treasure in itself, or horrifically disastrous, an unshakeable and lifelong curse.The BloodThe BrainsThe Eye or eyesThe Third Eye or the Secret or Invisible EyeThe TongueThe Horn or hornsThe ScalesThe Claws or nailsThe HeartThe LiverThe LungThe GlandsThe TearsThe IchorThe TailThe FootThe HandThe PawThe SnoutThe JawThe EarThe Tendril or TentacleThe Wings or feathersThe FinThe BileThe Stolen PartThe FleshThe MusclesThe ExcretionsThe prized and blood or ichor stained possessions of a monsterEach of these parts might render some beneficial aid to the possessor, or might render some monstrous curse. In the case of especially powerful or weird monsters, it might very well render both, and/or multiple effects.In addition such tissues or remains can be prepared, modified, presented, and intentionally used (with the right knowledge) for other employments, such as:Creating inks and parchmentsCreating Book materialsCreating unique potionsCreating unique magical itemsCreating technologies, machines, artifacts, and devicesCreating unique traps and tricksCreating illusionsCreating unique spells and powersDisrupting other things, objects, places, or eventsDispelling magicsEnhancing or disrupting miracles Augmenting or disrupting mental or psychological powersAugmenting or disrupting physical capabilitiesAugmenting or disrupting spiritual capabilitiesInvention, Design, and CraftSummoning or turning away other monstersSummoning or turning away the undeadSummoning or turning away demons and devilsForeseeing possible futuresSolving puzzlesOvercoming obstaclesDeveloping new scripts, ciphers, and codesGaining control over, or freeing other creaturesGaining control over, or freeing spiritsCommunicating secretly and/or over a distanceCreating GlammorsCreating powerful blessings or cursesMaking objects tough or nearly indestructibleDestroying other objectsExtending or shortening lifeCuring or causing diseaseCreating or controlling intense emotional statesCharming othersExciting Love, or HateAllowing flightHealing or preserving healthThe Effects – I will divide effects into obviously beneficial and obviously malignant effects. Some effects may seem to fall into both categories. Some effects can be viewed as blessings, others as curses. These effects can occur on the level of the individual, or on the cosmic level (effecting the world at large), or both, when the blood, tissues, and other remains or parts of a monster become exposed to a hero or the world through direct contact. These effects are not intentionally controllable but occur as a result of the unique properties of the monsters interacting with the unique nature of the individual or circumstance to which the blood or remains of the monster are exposed. These effects can also be acute, immediate, temporary, chronic, delayed, or life-long and permanent (unless somehow brought under control or removed).Beneficial Effects:Magical powers increaseSensory Capabilities improveOne can read the thoughts of othersOne can know the hearts of othersNew capabilities are gainedOne becomes strongerOne becomes wiserOne becomes more intelligentOne becomes more charismaticOne becomes more resilientOne becomes faster or more dexterousOne’s flesh becomes invulnerable to certain thingsOne rarely tires or rarely needs to sleepOne needs little foodOne needs little waterOne becomes powerfully intuitiveOne becomes propheticOne becomes clever and ingeniousOne can speak with monstersMalignant Effects:Magical powers decreaseSensory capabilities become clouded, restricted, or confusedOne’s own thoughts become scattered, confused, and open to suggestionOne becomes unable to understand the motives of othersOld capabilities are lost or diminishOne becomes weaker or feebleOne becomes more foolish, reckless, or unwiseOne becomes denser, slow-witted, or more stupid One becomes repugnant or repulsive to othersOne becomes drained, lethargic, or inflexibleOne becomes slow of body and reflexOne is easily injured or sickenedOne exhausts easily and often, or is chronically anemicOne becomes uncontrollably gluttonousOne becomes a drunkard or an addictOne becomes uncontrollably arrogant and pridefulOne becomes uncontrollably envious and covetousOne becomes uncontrollably lustfulOne becomes uncontrollably angry, petty, and ill-temperateOne becomes uncontrollably greedyOne becomes uncontrollably despairing and cynicalOne becomes uncontrollably slothful and lazyOne becomes uncontrollably bloodthirsty and viciousOne becomes easily duped and made fool ofOne becomes blindOne becomes deafOne becomes unable to smellOne becomes unable to tasteOne becomes leprousOne becomes muteOne contracts a chronic and perhaps incurable disease or conditionBlessings:Good fortune is enjoyedCrops become plentifulGood and pleasant weatherEnemies avoid invasion or warfareWater supplies are clean and plentifulThe earth is enriched, plants and animals thriveThe natural environment becomes filled with beneficial magicWealth increasesNew resources are discovered, old ones are easier to exploitMiracles occurThe Gift of Tongues – other languages can be understood, or the language of other creatures can be understoodPowerful and beneficial creatures or allies rein habit the areaTrade prospersResistances to malignant forces developCurses:Water becomes polluted, fouled, and poisonedThe air becomes poisonous and retchedFoul, dangerous, catastrophic, violently stormy weather Natural disasters aboundPlagues become commonDroughts develop and wild fires break outThe earth becomes weak, polluted, unyielding and unproductiveThe natural environment becomes resistant to beneficial magic or open to malignant magic or other influencesWealth decreases and resources become depletedTreasures corrupt or corrodeMisfortune multiplies or lingersConfusion and misunderstandings of speech and languageMalignant serpents, insects, and other creatures spring from the groundWarfare and Civil warfare eruptVulnerabilities to evil developThe Death Curse of the Monster: Sometimes at or near the moment of their death particularly powerful, intelligent, and malignant monsters might curse an individual, a party of people, or even an entire region or nation with an especially effective and malicious curse. In such cases extreme and immediate counter-measures must be taken, sometimes even involving the undertaking of a complicated Quest, it order to nullify or reverse this curse. Otherwise, if the curse is not counteracted it may very well unfold as prophesied in a most destructive and devastating manner.Conclusion: Make use of monsters, their blood, and their remains in a far more interesting, productive, potent, and imaginative way to reflect their real and inherent potential for creating both endless wonder, and appalling desolation. * I use the term uncanny poetically. I do not mean to imply that a monster must be supernatural (in the gaming or mythological sense) for its blood to have weird or powerful effects.</blockquote>

Verification