Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Maxperson" data-source="post: 9210074" data-attributes="member: 23751">I don't know where you are getting that from.&nbsp; All the non-human races you mentioned are not spirit beings who manifest in physical form.&nbsp; They are all distinct biological beings.&nbsp; All of them.There's nothing in the 5e PHB that says that elves are magical spirits. They are a magical race as evidenced by their racial abilities, but that doesn't make them spirits.&nbsp; They breed, have baby elves, grow and die of old age in 5e.I mean, that's a cool homebrew for you to use, but default 5e does not have those races as spirits taking humanlike forms.I mean, tieflings literally says the opposite. They were human and their pact with dark powers has changed their appearance.&nbsp; They aren't imitating anything.If you like.&nbsp; I'm not going to argue against your homebrew. Stuff like that is cool and there really isn't anything to argue against.&nbsp; I can like, dislike or be indifferent to it, but there's nothing to argue against.&nbsp; However, if you are claiming that 5e has made them spirits taken humanlike form, that I'm going to argue against because 5e doesn't say that.Even for spirits, level and age are not tied together.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Maxperson, post: 9210074, member: 23751"] I don't know where you are getting that from. All the non-human races you mentioned are not spirit beings who manifest in physical form. They are all distinct biological beings. All of them. There's nothing in the 5e PHB that says that elves are magical spirits. They are a magical race as evidenced by their racial abilities, but that doesn't make them spirits. They breed, have baby elves, grow and die of old age in 5e. I mean, that's a cool homebrew for you to use, but default 5e does not have those races as spirits taking humanlike forms. I mean, tieflings literally says the opposite. They were human and their pact with dark powers has changed their appearance. They aren't imitating anything. If you like. I'm not going to argue against your homebrew. Stuff like that is cool and there really isn't anything to argue against. I can like, dislike or be indifferent to it, but there's nothing to argue against. However, if you are claiming that 5e has made them spirits taken humanlike form, that I'm going to argue against because 5e doesn't say that. Even for spirits, level and age are not tied together. [/QUOTE]

Verification