Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Alzrius" data-source="post: 1418984" data-attributes="member: 8461">I wouldn't say that. The brief description they give of the plane is very much the same as that of the Far Realm. By contrast, nothing suggests its a &quot;plane of aberrations&quot;.The thing of it was though that my conclusion, while it was jumped to, was a leap in the direction the text seemed to indicate. Yours seemed to come totally out of left field. To be fair though, you had your reasons, which I address below:Gez already summed up the mind flayer one quite nicely, so I needn't repeat that. On the first two...just saying the creatures have a &quot;logical&quot; place in no way means that all aberrations come from that plane (or even any plane). It just means they have a history and a reason for being where they are now. It's still a complete shot in the dark to say that Xoriar is the plane where all aberrations come from, unlike the Far Realm.Why apologize? That's what we're doing. It's just that I want to conjecture with what seems most likely, not with &quot;what ifs&quot;.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Alzrius, post: 1418984, member: 8461"] I wouldn't say that. The brief description they give of the plane is very much the same as that of the Far Realm. By contrast, nothing suggests its a "plane of aberrations". The thing of it was though that my conclusion, while it was jumped to, was a leap in the direction the text seemed to indicate. Yours seemed to come totally out of left field. To be fair though, you had your reasons, which I address below: [I] Gez already summed up the mind flayer one quite nicely, so I needn't repeat that. On the first two...just saying the creatures have a "logical" place in no way means that all aberrations come from that plane (or even any plane). It just means they have a history and a reason for being where they are now. It's still a complete shot in the dark to say that Xoriar is the plane where all aberrations come from, unlike the Far Realm. Why apologize? That's what we're doing. It's just that I want to conjecture with what seems most likely, not with "what ifs".[/i] [/QUOTE]

Verification