Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Cheiromancer" data-source="post: 3765616" data-attributes="member: 141">No, I mean that "this piece of metal is one metre long" is an a priori, contingent truth.  When applied to one particular piece of metal, that is: the standard of the metre stored in Paris.  But that piece of reference is used to fix the reference; it could have been a different length (if the temperature it is stored at were a little higher or lower, say).Shouldn't it be that it ought to command every rational being's will?  It would be a little bit bootstrappy, but stranger positions have been entertained.Awesome.Why should I?  All I need to do is to be able to say, truthfully, that on some level you should care.  And I think that I can do this by being firmly oriented towards reality.  The problem is that the evolutionary games take so long to play out.  You can see things much clearer on the micro level, or on very long timescales.  Or both.  And heck, lets add across possible worlds.  Then what survives and reproduces survives and reproduces; all that there is are organisms obedient to the imperative to survive and reproduce.  Living things- even non-conscious ones- recognize that existence is good.  "Existence is good" - what cleaner way is there of bridging the is-ought gap?I don't see how rationality could come to be outside of evolution.  And so I don't see how it could be completely blind to the fact that existence is good.  It's not the whole story, of course, just the grain of sand inside the pearl.  There are all kinds of things that you can call bad, or even evil, even though they exist. Well, I guess it is fairly obvious that there is evil in the world.  But if you trace these judgments back through the well-tuned brains of fit organisms, you'll eventually come back to an imperative of genes to respond to the claim that "existence is good" - and they respond by striving to survive and reproduce.Anyway, I've done enough sidetracking of the thread for one night.  I hope its original purpose was more or less finished.</blockquote>

Verification