Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="gdmcbride" data-source="post: 5790213" data-attributes="member: 49338">I would note that definitive and best are two very different things.&nbsp;D&amp;D (basic) --B2 Keep on the Borderlands&nbsp;D&amp;D (expert) -- X1 Isle of Dread&nbsp;AD&amp;D --T1-4; A1-4; G1-3; D1-3; Q1 This sequence is the first adventure path. And yes I realize that it was stitched together only retroactively, but still this sequence of adventures was and is hugely influential.&nbsp;2ed -- No Definitive Adventure 2ed definitive setting -- PlanescapeI considered answering &quot;Dead Gods&quot; or &quot;Night Below&quot;, but then I realized the source of my dilemma at choosing one. This was not the time of adventures. This was the time of settings and fractured product lines. &nbsp;3ed -- Sunless Citadel&nbsp;3.5 -- Age of Worms AP Do you see that sequence of letter and numbers above beside my AD&amp;D entry? This is Paizo trying their level best to remake that feel using 3.5. In the history of adventure writing has there ever been a firmer codification of the D&amp;D save-the-world-from-evil story line than &quot;Age of Worms&quot;?&nbsp;4ed -- Keep on the Shadowfell&nbsp;Essentials -- Reavers of Harkenwold&nbsp;Pathfinder -- Rise of the Runelords (so far...)&nbsp;Gary McBride<a href="http://www.firemountaingames.com" target="_blank">Fire Mountain Games</a> maker of &quot;Way of the Wicked&quot; an evil adventure path compatible with the Pathfinder RPG that we hope will one day appear on this list as the definitive villianous campaign.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="gdmcbride, post: 5790213, member: 49338"] I would note that definitive and best are two very different things. D&D (basic) --[B]B2 Keep on the Borderlands[/B] D&D (expert) -- [B]X1 Isle of Dread[/B] AD&D --[B]T1-4; A1-4; G1-3; D1-3; Q1[/B] This sequence is the first adventure path. And yes I realize that it was stitched together only retroactively, but still this sequence of adventures was and is hugely influential. 2ed --[B] No Definitive Adventure[/B] 2ed definitive setting -- [B]Planescape[/B] I considered answering "Dead Gods" or "Night Below", but then I realized the source of my dilemma at choosing one. This was not the time of adventures. This was the time of settings and fractured product lines. 3ed -- [B]Sunless Citadel[/B] 3.5 -- [B]Age of Worms AP[/B] Do you see that sequence of letter and numbers above beside my AD&D entry? This is Paizo trying their level best to remake that feel using 3.5. In the history of adventure writing has there ever been a firmer codification of the D&D save-the-world-from-evil story line than "Age of Worms"? 4ed -- [B]Keep on the Shadowfell[/B] Essentials -- [B]Reavers of Harkenwold[/B] Pathfinder -- [B]Rise of the Runelords[/B] (so far...) Gary McBride [URL="http://www.firemountaingames.com"]Fire Mountain Games[/URL] maker of "Way of the Wicked" an evil adventure path compatible with the Pathfinder RPG that we hope will one day appear on this list as the definitive villianous campaign. [/QUOTE]

Verification