Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Nellisir" data-source="post: 8234666" data-attributes="member: 70">It was definitely the same posts repeating, not two people listing the same book. If I upvoted it, it remained upvoted. I suspect it has something to do with the fact that you can sort the whole thread in multiple ways.Posts already have a de facto &quot;upvote&quot; feature that people are already accustomed to using. It's the LIKE button. You could have this entire thread as-is, and just see what gets the most likes. Also removes the downvote option, which lowers conflict IMO.I agree the question tool is interesting and potentially cool, but I'm not convinced that a multi-page, ongoing thread is the best way to highlight it or the best use of it. It's also interesting that I didn't get any notices about this thread until you replied to me directly. I don't get notifications if someone adds a new post, which hasn't been my default settings, and possibly is an artifact of this being a non-standard item/thread/whatsit?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Nellisir, post: 8234666, member: 70"] It was definitely the same posts repeating, not two people listing the same book. If I upvoted it, it remained upvoted. I suspect it has something to do with the fact that you can sort the whole thread in multiple ways. Posts already have a de facto "upvote" feature that people are already accustomed to using. It's the LIKE button. You could have this entire thread as-is, and just see what gets the most likes. Also removes the downvote option, which lowers conflict IMO. I agree the question tool is interesting and potentially cool, but I'm not convinced that a multi-page, ongoing thread is the best way to highlight it or the best use of it. It's also interesting that I didn't get any notices about this thread until you replied to me directly. I don't get notifications if someone adds a new post, which hasn't been my default settings, and possibly is an artifact of this being a non-standard item/thread/whatsit? [/QUOTE]

Verification