Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="tetrasodium" data-source="post: 8721960" data-attributes="member: 93670">I don't think it's a problem to stop, but there are a few caveats to that.<ul> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">It winds up feeling like something is wrong & monsters are all braindead because if the monsters ever started doing it with competence it would make for a very fast TPK the GM would get blamed for.  This is a problem</li> <li data-xf-list-type="ul">Tools that used to mitigate that & encourage the PCs to focus on easily processed mooks or some kind of chess strategy to mitigate rather than trounce the big guy are no longer present & can not be added easily.</li> </ul>[spoiler="here is one"]Behind the curtain: Spell Resistance & Damage ReductionToo much spell resistance or damage reduction can' make a monster virtually unbeatable at the Challenge Rating you're aiming for. Too little, and the monster might as well not: have any at all. Since any character will have the caster level or magic weaponry necessary to penetrate the creature's defense.Spell Resistance: If you choose to give your monster this ability. you'll probably want to set the resistance number equal to the creature's CR+11 Tim means that a character of a level equal to the creature's will have a 50%”: chance to overcome the monster's spell resistance (Barring  Spell Penetration Feat). For example. a 12th-levecharacter has a 50% chance to overcome spell resistance 23, so 23 isa good spell res-stance number for a CR 12 creature.  You may need to adjust a creature's spell resistance number afteryou ﬁnally settle on a CR {or the creature...If you want a highly magic-resistant creature. set the monster's spell resistance higher than CR +11 For lesser resistance set the spell resistance lower. For each point of resistance. you'll change the change the chance of successfully overcoming spell resistance by 5%. For example. a 12tlevel caster has a 45% chance to overcome spell resistance 24. and no chance to overcome spell resistance 33Damage Reduction: Assigning a damage reduction value can be tricky. Setting the value. too high can make a creature virtually immuneto physical attacks. On the other hand. most player characters carry some magic weapons. so setting the value too low can result in an ineffective ability.RecommendedTarget CR         - Recommended Damage Reduction0~2                   - None3—5                  - 56—13                  -  1014-20                   - 15Remember. even if player characters can hurt the monster. lesser creatures in the game world often cannot hurt the creature. nor can theplayer character's cohorts or any creatures their summon.[/spoiler]Weapons like flametongue & such were important for regularly being able to do a guaranteed something against high DR monsters not for their ability to mow through trash monsters & mooks.  SR:Yes/No spells had very different functions & bolting them on is not the sort of thing that even fits in what could be called a houserule doc that is merely large & things like spell penetration hasn't even been mentioned yet.  flat DR & flat resist has more complications of their own.Adding old style flat DR & flat energy resist faces problems with needing to apply it (almost)everywhere or any tools given to players for dealing with it will light any hope of keeping player A & player B on a similar power scale of effectiveness to start but also comes with a secondary problem.  Players who started with 5e have no idea what is impeding them and get upset that it's still impeding them even though they have a magic weapon  or they ignore any attempt made to explain why other weapons are important & refuse to consider them if those other weapons are not immediately & obviously better in all situations.  Either way the result looks like a failure on the GM's part</blockquote>

Verification