Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Maxperson" data-source="post: 8746900" data-attributes="member: 23751">I have explained it clearly. In the world mundane items and creatures are NOT magical.&nbsp; They just aren't.&nbsp; Magic in the D&amp;D universe is like the force.&nbsp; It flows in and around all things, but only those who can actually use the force have magic.&nbsp; Some creatures can do this innately.&nbsp; Normal Giant Spiders are not one of those creatures.So is the one that was summoned.&nbsp; None of them are magical.&nbsp; They are simply creatures.&nbsp; The magic is in the summoning, not the elemental. A ghoul is not magical.&nbsp; Some of them can be created through magic.&nbsp; Others arise spontaneously.&nbsp; The result, though, is an undead creature connected to the negative plane. Ghouls have some innate magical ability, but that does not make them magical.&nbsp; Their attacks will not go through the resistance of a creature that is immune to normal weapons.I am using them correctly.&nbsp; Your coherent explanation is anything but. Creatures are not all magical just because magic(the force) is everywhere or they originated magically(undead animation). Create Food and Water makes entirely unmagical food and water.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Maxperson, post: 8746900, member: 23751"] I have explained it clearly. In the world mundane items and creatures are NOT magical. They just aren't. Magic in the D&D universe is like the force. It flows in and around all things, but only those who can actually use the force have magic. Some creatures can do this innately. Normal Giant Spiders are not one of those creatures. So is the one that was summoned. None of them are magical. They are simply creatures. The magic is in the summoning, not the elemental. A ghoul is not magical. Some of them can be created through magic. Others arise spontaneously. The result, though, is an undead creature connected to the negative plane. Ghouls have some innate magical ability, but that does not make them magical. Their attacks will not go through the resistance of a creature that is immune to normal weapons. I am using them correctly. Your coherent explanation is anything but. Creatures are not all magical just because magic(the force) is everywhere or they originated magically(undead animation). Create Food and Water makes entirely unmagical food and water. [/QUOTE]

Verification