Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 6346051" data-attributes="member: 22779">You're both missing the point.&nbsp; I want both of us to get what we want.&nbsp; I want you to have an entire line of Planescape books, big, beautiful books and boxed sets and minis and whatnot.&nbsp; More stuff than you could possibly buy.&nbsp; I want you to have that.I would just rather that there is also core books that deal with the planes that aren't Planescape.&nbsp; Same as everything else in D&amp;D.&nbsp; Of course I can refluff anything.&nbsp; I just want to buy books as well.&nbsp; Again, I just don't understand it.&nbsp; Why is it so terrible to put Planescape in the Planescape box and leave core alone?&nbsp; Why is it better for the game to make Planescape the default setting for all planar material?&nbsp; We don't do this for any other setting.&nbsp; No other setting gets this treatment and it continues to baffle me why Planescape gets the pass.&nbsp; What really baffles me is why people not only accept it, but encourage it.If we did this with any other setting, we'd get crucified.&nbsp; Heck, look at the reactions to having Dragonborn in core.&nbsp; Or the complaints that Tieflings are not Planescape Tieflings.&nbsp; Imagine how freaked people would get if we forced Eberron orcs and goblins into core.&nbsp; Or all vampires MUST be Ravenloft vampires and follow Ravenloft canon in every core supplement.&nbsp; People would go ape.&nbsp; But, planar stuff?&nbsp; Oh, that has to be Planescape or nothing.&nbsp; Why isn't there a middle road where we all get something?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 6346051, member: 22779"] You're both missing the point. I want both of us to get what we want. I want you to have an entire line of Planescape books, big, beautiful books and boxed sets and minis and whatnot. More stuff than you could possibly buy. I want you to have that. I would just rather that there is also core books that deal with the planes that aren't Planescape. Same as everything else in D&D. Of course I can refluff anything. I just want to buy books as well. Again, I just don't understand it. Why is it so terrible to put Planescape in the Planescape box and leave core alone? Why is it better for the game to make Planescape the default setting for all planar material? We don't do this for any other setting. No other setting gets this treatment and it continues to baffle me why Planescape gets the pass. What really baffles me is why people not only accept it, but encourage it. If we did this with any other setting, we'd get crucified. Heck, look at the reactions to having Dragonborn in core. Or the complaints that Tieflings are not Planescape Tieflings. Imagine how freaked people would get if we forced Eberron orcs and goblins into core. Or all vampires MUST be Ravenloft vampires and follow Ravenloft canon in every core supplement. People would go ape. But, planar stuff? Oh, that has to be Planescape or nothing. Why isn't there a middle road where we all get something? [/QUOTE]

Verification